Blog Layout

PROVING FAULT IN PERSONAL INJURY CLAIMS

Admin • April 29, 2021

A plaintiff in an auto accident case must prove the defendant's liability to get compensation. Below are some legal theories you can use to prove liability.


Negligence

Negligence is a legal principle that makes someone liable for your injury if their carelessness has caused your injury. You must prove the following elements to succeed with a negligence claim:

  • Duty: You need to prove that the defendant had a legal obligation to act in a manner that wouldn't harm you. For example, as a pedestrian, other road users (such as motorists) have a legal obligation to drive safely to not harm you.
  • Breach: Secondly, you must prove that the defendant failed in their duty of care. For example, a motorist who doesn't stop at a pedestrian crossing has breached their duty of care to pedestrians.
  • Causation: Third, you must prove that the defendant's breach caused your injury. For example, a driver can cause your injury by running the red light and knocking you down.
  • Damages: Lastly, you must prove that the defendant's actions caused your actual injuries. That is, a near-miss of scare doesn't count - you must suffer actual injuries to succeed with a negligent claim.


Negligence Per Se

Negligence per se is a stricter form of conventional negligence law. You must prove these things:

  • The Defendant Violated a Law: Negligence per se claims only apply to cases where the defendant has breached an existing law or regulation. For example, the law requires motorists to stop when a school bus stops. Therefore, a motorist who overtakes a stopped school bus violates that law.
  • The Law Enhanced Public Safety: Negligence per se claims only apply to violations of public safety laws. For example, the school bus law above keeps children safe since they lack the awareness to cross highways or roads safely.
  • You Belong to the Class the Law Protects: You must prove that you are a member of the class that the violated law protects. These laws don't apply if a motorist overtakes a stopped bus and knocks you down, but you are not a student, and you weren't on the bus.


Strict Liability

The two forms of negligence above aren't the only ways to prove liability in an accident. You can also use the legal theory of strict liability. This legal theory applies fault to a defendant without regard to the defendant's fault.
Here is what you must prove to succeed with a strict liability claim:

  • The Defendant's Actions Were Unusually Dangerous: Strict liability only applies to activities that carry an unusual level of danger. For example, transporting explosives is a highly hazardous activity, so it's subject to strict liability laws.
  • You Suffered Injuries: You must also prove that you suffered actual injuries. Medical treatment history is usually adequate proof.
  • The Defendant's Action's Caused Your Injuries: You must also link the defendant's actions directly to your injuries. For example, you cannot use a strict liability claim if you crash your car due to distraction by a burning explosives truck.


Intentional Conduct

Lastly, you can also use intentional tort law to make someone pay for your injuries. Intentional tort laws apply to intentional acts or conduct. Here is what you must prove in this case:

  • The Defendant Acted Intentionally: Intentional tort only applies if the defendant intended to commit the alleged act. For example, a driver commits an intentional act if they ram another car in a fit of road rage. Thus, road rage can trigger an intentional tort claim.
  • The Defendant Caused You Injury: Secondly, you must tie the defendant's intentional act to your injury. Indirect injuries don't count.
  • The Defendant Foresaw Your Injury: Lastly, you must prove that the defendant knew or should have known that their actions would cause you injury. For example, all drivers know that crashing into another car can cause injury.


Spooner & Perkins Attorneys at Law have decades of legal experience. Contact us to evaluate your case and help you pursue your accident damages.

December 19, 2024
If you have been awarded workers' compensation benefits, read our blog to learn how these benefits can interact with any of your existing benefits.
November 20, 2024
Burn injuries in the workplace can be devastating, both physically and emotionally. Learn more here about how a workers' compensation lawyer can help.
October 22, 2024
If you've been injured on the job, you may be entitled to workers' compensation benefits. These benefits are designed to cover medical expenses and lost wages while you recover from your injury. However, navigating the workers' comp claim process can be confusing and overwhelming. That's why it's important to know when to call a lawyer for your workers' comp claim. In this blog post, we'll discuss the situations where it may be necessary to seek legal representation for your workers' comp claim. By understanding these scenarios, you can ensure that you receive the full benefits you're entitled to under the law. Denial of Your Claim One of the main reasons to call a lawyer for your workers' comp claim is if your claim has been denied. Unfortunately, insurance companies often deny valid claims to save money. If this happens, it's important to have an experienced workers' compensation lawyer on your side who can fight for your rights. They can review the details of your case and gather evidence to support your claim, making it difficult for the insurance company to deny you the benefits you deserve. Appealing a Decision If your initial claim is denied or if you feel that you're not receiving the full amount of benefits you're entitled to, you may need to appeal the decision. This process can be complex and time-consuming, but having a lawyer on your side can make it easier. They can handle all the legal aspects of your appeal and ensure that you have the best chance of getting the benefits you deserve. Pre-Existing Conditions If you have a pre-existing condition that has been aggravated by a work-related injury, it may be necessary to call a lawyer for your workers' comp claim. Insurance companies often use pre-existing conditions as an excuse to deny or limit benefits. However, with the help of a lawyer, you can prove that your current injury is directly related to your job and receive the full benefits you're entitled to. Disputes over Medical Treatment or Benefits In some cases, you may be involved in a dispute with your employer or the insurance company over the type of medical treatment you're receiving or the amount of benefits you're entitled to. This can be a frustrating and stressful experience, but with a lawyer by your side, you can have someone who knows the law on your side. They can fight for your rights and ensure that you receive proper medical care and fair compensation. Permanent Disability If your workplace injury has resulted in permanent disability, it's important to call a lawyer for your workers' comp claim. Permanent disability benefits are often complex and difficult to calculate, especially if there are future medical expenses involved. A lawyer can help determine the full extent of your disability and ensure that you receive the appropriate benefits to cover your needs. Employer Retaliation Unfortunately, some employers may retaliate against employees who file workers' comp claims. This can come in the form of demotions, pay cuts, or even termination. If you feel like your employer is treating you unfairly because of your claim, it's important to call a lawyer. They can protect your rights and help you take legal action against any form of retaliation. Navigating a workers' comp claim can be overwhelming, especially if it involves legal disputes and complex calculations. That's why it's important to know when it's time to call a lawyer for your workers' comp claim. If you find yourself in any of the situations mentioned above, it's best to seek legal representation from a qualified workers' compensation lawyer. So, don’t hesitate to seek assistance if you feel overwhelmed or encounter any issues during your workers’ comp claim process. For more info, contact us at Spooner & Perkins, P.C.
September 25, 2024
Can medication use at work and a workplace injury cause you to lose out on workers' compensation? Read on to learn more and why hiring an attorney is key.
August 29, 2024
Read our blog to explore different accidents common on construction sites and how workers' compensation helps injured workers get compensated.
By Adrian Ranawat July 31, 2024
Receive a head injury at work? Read this article to learn about the complexities of workers' compensation for brain injuries in this comprehensive guide.
July 6, 2024
Read this blog to learn some key factors that can influence your workers' compensation. Understand these changes to ensure fair support for your case.
June 5, 2024
It's essential for remote workers to understand their rights and responsibilities regarding workers' compensation. Read on to learn more.
April 23, 2024
Read this article to explore the types of workplace trauma eligible for workers comp and learn about the claim process, rights, and more.
April 2, 2024
Losing a loved one in a fatal work accident is challenging. Read on to learn the benefits of hiring an attorney after a loved one dies in a work accident.
More Posts
Share by: